The Leadership Paradox: Why True Care Drives Exceptional Results
Photo by cottonbro studio
"The challenge of leadership is to be strong, but not rude; be kind, but not weak; be bold, but not bully; be thoughtful, but not lazy; be humble, but not timid; be proud, but not arrogant; have humor, but without folly."
— Jim Rohn
Results matter—a lot. In both our personal and professional lives, we strive for meaningful outcomes. But here’s the paradox: the harder we focus solely on achieving results, the more elusive they can become. Why? Because while results are critical, the way we achieve them—how we treat people, nurture relationships, and foster genuine engagement—matters just as much. In fact, it’s not just a feel-good sentiment; it’s a strategic imperative that directly shapes the very outcomes we aim to achieve.
Leaders often fall into the trap of focusing on one side of the equation while neglecting the other. Some become so results-obsessed that they trample over people in their pursuit of success. While this approach might yield short-term gains, driven by fear and survival instincts, it inevitably backfires.
On the other hand, leaders who focus solely on maintaining harmony and protecting feelings can lose sight of performance. This approach can lead to complacency, where underperformance goes unaddressed to avoid discomfort. Over time, it can erode accountability, stifle growth, and create a culture where mediocrity is tolerated instead of excellence being pursued. Neither extreme is sustainable. The real art of leadership lies in finding the balance between these seemingly opposing forces.
Finding the Balance in Action
I witnessed this balance firsthand during a challenging oil and gas project. The project director, David, had invested countless hours in the field with his team. He knew hundreds of workers by name and took a genuine interest in their lives. When unprecedented rains put the project dangerously behind schedule, David called an all-hands meeting. He was direct about the dire situation and asked for their help.
The response was extraordinary. The team doubled down, made up for lost time, and did so without a single safety incident. This wasn’t just about what David asked—it was about who was asking: a leader who had consistently shown genuine care for his people. David regularly walked the site, engaged in meaningful conversations beyond work topics, remembered personal details about his team members, and celebrated their achievements, both big and small. He created an environment where people felt seen, valued, and respected, which built the trust and loyalty that inspired his team to rise to the challenge when it mattered most.
Masters of this balance understand that caring deeply and demanding excellence aren’t mutually exclusive; they’re mutually reinforcing. Take Phil Jackson, known as the "Zen Master" of basketball. Leading the Chicago Bulls and LA Lakers to eleven NBA championships, Jackson was renowned for nurturing not just athletes but the whole person. He introduced meditation to his players, recommended books tailored to their personal growth, and helped each individual find their unique role within the team. Yet, he was relentless in his pursuit of excellence, pushing superstars like Michael Jordan and Kobe Bryant to transcend even their extraordinary capabilities.
Consider also Paul O’Neill’s transformation of Alcoa. When he became CEO in 1987, he shocked Wall Street by declaring that his top priority wouldn’t be profits but worker safety. Critics thought he was sacrificing results for feel-good initiatives. They couldn’t have been more wrong. Under O’Neill’s leadership, Alcoa’s worker injury rate plummeted to one-twentieth of the U.S. average, while the company’s market capitalization grew by $27 billion. By genuinely caring about his employees’ well-being, O’Neill built the trust and commitment needed to drive unparalleled performance.
The Foundation of True Leadership
These leaders understood something fundamental: genuine care isn’t a soft skill—it’s the bedrock of high expectations. A common misconception is that 'soft skills' like empathy, active listening, and relationship-building are secondary to hard metrics like productivity and efficiency. In reality, these so-called soft skills are critical leadership competencies that foster trust, drive engagement, and create the psychological safety necessary for people to perform at their best. Think about how we treat those closest to us—our partners, children, or best friends. Because we care deeply about their growth and success, we’re willing to have tough conversations and hold them to high standards. We do this because we care about their potential.
The trap many leaders fall into is believing they must choose between being respected and being liked, between driving results and building relationships. But true leadership transcends this false dichotomy.
Practical Steps to Achieve the Balance
So how do we create an environment where both care and accountability thrive? Here are key principles to guide the way:
1. Genuine Care Cannot Be Faked
People have an innate ability to detect authenticity. Take time to truly know your team—their aspirations, challenges, and what matters most to them. Like David, invest in being present, listening actively, and demonstrating through consistent actions that you care about their well-being and growth.
2. High Standards Are a Form of Respect
Holding people accountable to high standards isn’t about being harsh for its own sake; it’s about honoring their potential. When we believe in someone’s capabilities, we challenge them to rise to their best. The key is ensuring this push comes from a place of genuine care for their development and success.
3. Create Safety Before Driving Accountability
Psychological safety is the foundation for accountability. When people feel safe to speak up, make mistakes, and express concerns without fear of humiliation or punishment, they’re more likely to take risks, innovate, and hold themselves accountable. This isn’t about lowering expectations—it’s about creating the conditions for people to thrive.
4. Sustainable Results Come from Commitment, Not Compliance
When people know you genuinely care about them, they’ll go above and beyond—not because they’re forced to, but because they want to. They’ll problem-solve creatively, support their colleagues, and take ownership in ways that no amount of pressure or control can achieve.
The Real Paradox of Leadership
The paradox of results isn’t really a paradox at all. Caring deeply and demanding greatness aren’t opposing forces—they’re complementary elements of effective leadership. When we get this balance right, we create conditions for both exceptional results and extraordinary human development.
So, as you reflect on your own leadership journey, ask yourself: Am I fostering an environment where people feel both deeply valued and expected to achieve their best? Choose to lead with both heart and high expectations—and watch the extraordinary unfold.
~ Eduardo
Fundamental of the Week #14: DELIVER RESULTS
Set high goals without overpromising. Track and measure your progress, and hold yourself and others accountable for delivering consistent results.
Momentum Consulting offers executive business coaching, top-level executive consulting, team training, and team off-sites to build and transform your business to the next level. Inquire about business consulting and leadership coaching today.
